I have been trying to perfect matzo ball soup for 10 years, and have tried dozens of recipes. I can assure you that you need not look any further for a recipe. This is THE ONE!! I've printed the original recipe here, but I made a few shortcuts and and this was still my best soup yet: I simmered the chicken for just 1 1/2 hours instead of 2, because I had a hungry crew waiting for this soup. At that time, I removed the chicken and veggies from the pot, set aside to cool, and shredded the chicken. Meanwhile, I kept the soup at a simmer, and tossed the matzo balls right in. After 30 minutes the matzo balls were done, I ladled the broth and the balls into bowls, then topped with the shredded chicken, the cooked carrots, and minced dill. This shortcut cuts an hour off of the Shiksa's recipe. (Note: I highly recommend Shiksa's technique of wrapping the chicken in cheesecloth before placing in the pot - saves straining hassle)
The result: a rich, delicious, fragrant soup. Yes, fragrant! Perfection in a bowl.
- 1 or 2 whole chickens, 3-5 pounds total, including neck
- (use more chicken if you’re making a larger pot, or for a meatier soup)
- 4 celery stalks with leaves, chopped into thirds
- 4 whole carrots, chopped into thirds; or 1 1/2 cups of baby carrots
- 1 large brown onion rinsed and halved, outer skin intact
- 5 sprigs of fresh curly-leafed parsley
- 1 tbsp whole black peppercorns
- ½ tbsp whole cloves
- 2 bay leaves
- 1/2 bunch of fresh dill, lower stems removed
- Kosher or sea salt to taste
- Lemon juice (optional)
- Matzo ball mix (I prefer Manischewitz)
- Vegetable oil or schmaltz
Rinse the chicken and place it in a tall stockpot. Cover the chicken with water, reserving about 3 inches of space at the top of the pot. Bring to a slow boil over medium high heat. As the chicken cooks, a fatty foam will start to rise. Skim this foam from the surface.
Add celery, carrots, onion, parsley, peppercorns, cloves, bay leaves, and a few sprigs of the dill to the pot. Add 1 tbsp of salt, then stir till all the vegetables are moistened and simmering in the broth. Cover pot, reduce heat to medium, and allow pot to simmer for two hours. Mince the remaining dill and set aside.
After the soup has simmered for two hours, allow it to cool for 30 minutes. While soup is cooling, prepare the matzo ball mix according to package directions. You can add a couple of tablespoons of the minced fresh dill into the mix. Place prepared matzo ball mix in the refrigerator.
Strain the broth with a mesh strainer. Pull meat from the chicken in bite-sized pieces and return to the broth. Return vegetables to the broth, if desired. Add the remaining minced dill to the stockpot, then return the soup to a slow simmer. Taste the broth. Add more salt, if desired. Be sure to add slowly, don’t over-salt!
Remove prepared matzo ball mix from refrigerator. Form mixture into about a dozen 1 inch balls and place gently into the simmering soup. Don’t make the balls too large, they will expand a lot in the broth.
Reduce heat, cover, and simmer for 30 minutes more, or until matzo balls have fully expanded. When soup is finished, stir gently to separate any dill that might have gathered on the surface of the soup.
Serve with two or three matzo balls and some chicken pieces in each soup bowl. Garnish with a lemon slice, if desired. If you don’t plan on serving the whole pot of soup at one sitting, make sure you remove the matzo balls from the broth and refrigerate them in a separate container. Otherwise they’ll turn mushy.
Hint: To make straining easier, tie up all the stock ingredients tightly in a few layers of cheesecloth before covering with water. When the stock has finished cooking, just remove the cheesecloth and unwrap the chicken. You can also cook the stock in a steel multi-pot with a mesh strainer insert (fine mesh—strainers with large holes will let the spices seep through). Both of these methods will allow you to skip straining the broth into another pot!